eftychia: Me in poufy shirt, kilt, and Darth Vader mask, playing a bouzouki (vader)
Add MemoryShare This Entry

I just caught a Christmas-themed commercial on television, with a carol as the soundtrack and images of Christmas trees and Santa. [While writing this, a second one came on.] In case anyone hasn't noticed, or is reading this weeks from now without looking at the timestamp, it is not yet Samhain (All Hallows), much less (US) Thanksgiving. I also note that a friend on the other coast described an in-person sighting of Christmas mall-decorations going up already, a few days ago.

May I please get time to enjoy the holidays ahead of it before we get into full Christmas overload (which also makes it harder, at least for me, to enjoy Christmas itself as much)? Clearly, the not-commercialized Christian holidays are getting not only shortchanged, but in the case of All Hallows (aka All Saints Day) and All Souls they're actually being obscured, papered over (in wrapping paper) by the Christmas-and-no-other-holidays crowd. Or is it that they're not-Protestant rather than not-commercial? The non-church-holiday-but-still-with-religious-overtones Thanksgiving is being denied its proper time in our attention as well, saved from being completely ignored only thanks to its football matches and ... its customary, but now apparently obsolete, role marking the start of the Commercemas Christmas shopping season. And Samhain, the Celtic New Year holiday from which we borrowed some of our older All Saints Eve (Hallow E'en) traditions and use as the inspiration excuse for most of our modern ones is clearly a major target of this War On All Holidays Other Than Christmas -- are the Catholic holidays serious targets as well, or mere "collateral damage" in this war?

Either way, it's clear that the economic weight of Christmas, the 800-pound gorilla of holidays, is being used to crush other holidays, drive them into obscurity, and prevent those of us who value tradition and wish to remember the reason for every season from being permitted to properly celebrate Other Holidays as they are meant to be celebrated -- that is, as holidays in their own right, not merely as landmarks on the road to Christmas!

We who care about any of these other holidays must stand up for our rights! Do not let them diminish the rest of the holidays! We are being oppressed, and if we do not challenge this annual expansion of Christmas, stop the slide down this slippery slope, sooner or later there will be nothing left in the calendar -- no Flag Day, no Independence Day, no Easter, only Christmas, Boxing Day, and three hundred and sixty three days of Christmas Eve! Look at how Lincoln's and Washington's birthdays have already been crushed, smooshed together into a single, unremarkable (except for linen sales) "Presidents Day"! Every holiday you hold dear is at risk if you do not act.

The Jewish major holidays have been poorly represented in public consciousness for a long time, with the minor Channukah elevated to prominence as part of the backdrop for Christmas. And the Muslim calendar is so poorly understood on these shores that most people have no clue when its holidays are -- count the number of times you hear "Happy Ramadan" this December despite the month of Ramadan having ended about a week before the end of October (this year ... it'll be even funnier in years when Ramadan happens in July). I've already mentioned what happened to George Washington and Abraham Lincoln, and to assorted Catholic Holidays that Aren't Christmas. So I say to you: Muslims, you are being oppressed; Catholics, you are being oppressed; Patriots, you are being oppressed; Jews, you are being oppressed (yet again); and Protestants who believe Easter is a more important religious holiday than Christmas (everybody has a birthday -- how many have a rebirth-day, huh?), you too are being oppressed! Old-calendar Orthodox Christians, you are being oppressed (do you think any of these Noelists are going to wish you Merry Christmas in January? But you do get to take advantage of the "after Christmas" sales for your Christmas shopping, which is some compensation...) So it's clearly not simply a "Christians gainst everybody else" thing, as some of the Christmas Over Everything people try to portray it, since even some (many!) Christians get short shrift here -- don't let them get away with this.

Protest to the shopkeepers, those craven servants of "political correctness" who have bowed to the pressure of the Noelists (or have been bribed by their shopping money) to replace these other holidays with ever more Christmas, however they try to Disguise their Christmasism with supposedly innocuous "Happy Holidays" (as if they were paying attention to any holidays not contemporaneous with Christmas -- ha!) and "Season's Greetings" (note how no other season is credited with its own greeting?). Boycott the stores, even entire malls, that start Christmas too early and trample the freedom of those who would celebrate Hallowe'en and Thanksgiving as holidays separate from Christmas, preferring to celebrate Christmas in its own season instead of in other holidays' time! Make certain that the media understand that we are tired of this War Against Holidays Other Than Christmas and that we are equally tired of being dismissed as inconsequential cranks. Remind them that we speak for countless others too cowed by commercial political correctness to give voice to their own dismay at the obscuring of the other holidays -- the lurkers support us in email!. Insist on being greeted with "The Monster Mash" instead of Christmas carols tomorrow and the next day, with "Boo!" or "Happy Hallowe'en" instead of garlands and Christmas trees. Insist that until Thanksgiving we honour the memory of those who settled this great nation , and overeating, with pretty autumnal brown and orange and gold (which make the red and green and tinsel of Christmas seem all the more special when they show up as the transition from the Thanksgiving decorations than when they've been up so long they become background noise -- the Noelists are harming their own favourite holiday in their quest to drive all other holidays down). If you enter a store before Thanksgiving and see a Santa hat, find the manager and insist it be replaced by a hat with a buckle on it. Don't let them crush our holidays!

And if anybody says anything about a so-called "War On Christmas", remind them that Christmas started it!

There are 26 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
ext_18496: Me at work circa 2007 (Default)
posted by [identity profile] thatcrazycajun.livejournal.com at 10:57pm on 2006-10-29
I share your peeve in this regard and applaud your eloquent call to arms. Unfortunately, so long as the retail sector continues to depend on Christmas-season sales for up to half of their annual receipts, this trend will likely continue despite our efforts...and accelerate. "In the end, there can be only one..." Christmas uber alles!
 
posted by [identity profile] lysystratae.livejournal.com at 06:38am on 2006-10-30
not if we can get everyone who hates this to refuse to buy any of it before the proper time of year! If the stores see that their revenue goes down the earlier they bring the stuff out, they'll shift back in the other direction until they find a middle point.
 
posted by [identity profile] dianec42.livejournal.com at 12:51am on 2006-10-31
Sadly, I think "everyone who hates this" is a subset of "everyone who uses their brain to think about things", so it's probably too small a group to be noticed.
 
posted by [identity profile] lysystratae.livejournal.com at 03:07am on 2006-10-31
Hmmm... as usual, Daria ;) has a good point
 
posted by [identity profile] jhayman.livejournal.com at 11:12pm on 2006-10-29
I agree with what you're saying!

However, I would note that All Saints and All Souls are observed by some non-Catholic Christian church as days of veneration. Thanksgiving for harvest also goes well beyond the US and is observed as a church service in some faiths.

I think the December spending has absolutely nothing to do with Christmas. It's Santa Day and we must spend, spend, spend. The giving of gifts to celebrate the rebirth of light is a gift of hope. What we do is an obscenity, driven, as you say, by economic powers.

I LOVE holdays and observance. The Santa Day juggernaut truly does obliterate everything else. And it completely despoils the slow procession of the fall into the growing darkness that asks us to be mindful during the days of Advent, followed by the great joy of Christmas, when light once again rules.
 
posted by [identity profile] sensualquills.livejournal.com at 11:45pm on 2006-10-29
another welldone essay dear. thoroughly impressed, thoroughly in agreement. i too have been seeing a few dept. store commercials with misletoe in toe. UGH. i looooove halloween. it's my favorite holiday, and even my birthday is #2 on the list in comparison. i'm glad you said it first.
 
posted by [identity profile] jeanniemac.livejournal.com at 12:08am on 2006-10-30
Bravo. I couldn't agree more. I had such a powerful experience at the Samhain ritual last night and it was really hard to walk by that tree on my way to run errands this morning.

Although I will correct you on one small detail. The tree I saw was actually a municple tree, put up by the city, not the mall. The mall is just as bad but not quite that blatent yet.
 
posted by [identity profile] realinterrobang.livejournal.com at 02:44am on 2006-10-30
We atheists in the crowd are being ultimately oppressed, because although we don't mind the time off work, we really wish that our entire culture didn't go prune-pudding-for-brains insane periodically. The only reason I do Christmas at all is because of my family. (That said, I think everyone who does Christmas should do a big shindig Christmas...once in their life, just to see what the fuss is about, but doing it every bloody year like my family does is just an onerous chore.)

It's tedious. It's boring. It's an unnecessary expense. Not only that, but most public religious holiday observance is so trite, it's sickening.
 
posted by [identity profile] wouldyoueva.livejournal.com at 05:01am on 2006-10-30
And this is why I shop so close to Christmas: to give the retailers a message that we're tired of this crap. Every year around December 10th the retailers complain that shoppers aren't buying as much and they're not going to do well. And then people go out and shop. You'd think they'd get the message someday.

But poor New Year's Eve! It gets only a week of people anticipating it, and it gets buried in Valentine's candy going on the shelves.
 
posted by [identity profile] selki.livejournal.com at 06:30am on 2006-10-30
And if anybody says anything about a so-called "War On Christmas", remind them that Christmas started it!

Well put!

Does face paint have fumes? I'd like to do Halloween as Zombie Santa some year, protesting the overcommercialization of Christmas, but I need to breathe, too.

Also: part protest, part performance art: the Church of Stop Shopping
 
posted by [identity profile] lysystratae.livejournal.com at 06:36am on 2006-10-30
Hear, hear!

So far, I've seen full-on christmas displays in Kmart; Target, Walgreens and CVS are all bringing out the christmas stuff only as the Halloween and harvest-themed items sell down, so that's a small compromise (mind you, since the harvest-themed stuff is only a couple shelves worth, that's not saying alot. I want Thanksgiving decorations, dammit!)
 
posted by [identity profile] buubala.livejournal.com at 07:35am on 2006-10-30
I agree. I do not shop until Christmas Eve if at all. I would rather give my nephew or sister's money. In GA right now they have already put out Christmas stuff and that is just wrong. It seems at least to me that they have put off Thanksgiving to the side completely. And no you dont go too far.
 
posted by [identity profile] lpetrazickis.livejournal.com at 12:28pm on 2006-10-30
I hate Thanksgiving because:
1. I hate Turkey.
2. I hate spending time with my clan.
3. We Canadians get two of them.
4. Being arbitrarily grateful is silly.
 
posted by [identity profile] qfyd.livejournal.com at 01:05pm on 2006-10-30
Interesting that you should mention Ramadan, as it allows me to recount something I saw last year.

I don't know if you have the same thing in the states (I think you do because I saw it in the movie Bad Santa) but here we have these over priced poor quality chocolate dispensing mechanisms called advent calendars.

Personally I think They're a covert way to prepare people for a life of taking daily medication from bubble packaging but that's by the by. Back when I lived in Leicester (which is probably the most culturally diverse city in Britain, one of the few places where immigrants outnumber racists) I saw chocolate filled Ramadan calendars on sale in the local ASDA (our variant of Walmart)

From what I can tell, shops are clearly trying to push the other holidays in an attempt to make them as profitable as Christmas, but until we start buying our kids Playstation 2s for Easter, Christmas is where the money is.
 
posted by [identity profile] dptwisted.livejournal.com at 01:24pm on 2006-10-30
Advent calendars for Ramadan? Chocolate goodies for a fasting ritual? What's next, Vegas Getaways for Lent?
 
posted by [identity profile] qfyd.livejournal.com at 01:33pm on 2006-10-30
See that's what I thought, but as I know so little about the festive calendars of other cultures, I assumed there was some aspect of Ramadan which validated it. On most month-long fasts I recall from my long-long-ago religious education lessons, there were a few hours of the day when eating was okay, as a method of actually not starving to death. Perhaps the chocolate is to reward kids for a full days fast the day before...
 
posted by [identity profile] leiacat.livejournal.com at 02:46pm on 2006-10-30
It makes sense - from what I hear, once the sun goes down, the party starts. I can see the chocolate being something extra to look forward to.
 
posted by [identity profile] old-hedwig.livejournal.com at 08:13pm on 2006-10-30
Ramadan is a complete fast (unlike Lent or Advent no meat/dairy/oil small meals no snacks type fasting) during daylight, and each day when the sun goes down there can be feasting with family and friends. Because of the way the calendar is figured, the length of the day nd thus of the fast varies from year to year.
 
posted by [identity profile] old-hedwig.livejournal.com at 08:19pm on 2006-10-30
I'm Catholic, I celebrate Advent during most of December, and Christmas from evening on December 24 until 12th night. I like to make a lot of my gifts and decorations, so I can appreciate craft stores and such starting to show winter ideas early, but if I'm going to the store to buy as sack of floour or a pair of jeans (or a bag of Halloween candy) the last thing I want to see in the middle of Autumn is a bunch of Christmas stuff. In addition to glossing over other holidays and observances, I don't want to be already sick of Christmas (and have my greens looking all tired and dried out) before the actual 12-day holiday even starts.
 
posted by [identity profile] dianec42.livejournal.com at 12:51am on 2006-10-31
And if anybody says anything about a so-called "War On Christmas", remind them that Christmas started it!

I love you.
silveradept: A kodama with a trombone. The trombone is playing music, even though it is held in a rest position (Default)
posted by [personal profile] silveradept at 03:36am on 2006-10-31
Hear, hear. I'm tired of having the October and November Holidays ignored in favor of one that doesn't happen until the end part of December. Everything in due time, my merchant friends. Relax and wait for it. It'll do you better not to stress so very much.
 
posted by [identity profile] garnet-rattler.livejournal.com at 03:53am on 2006-10-31
Christmas used to be a good deal for me. My housemates went home for a week and left me to a calm, quiet and peaceful ~holiday. Dragging it out for several months just degrades the whole idea. Let the 'War on Christmas' begin!
 
posted by [identity profile] blumindy.livejournal.com at 04:25am on 2006-10-31
*snerk*
 
posted by [identity profile] flaviarassen.livejournal.com at 07:55am on 2006-10-31
The Jewish major holidays have been poorly represented in
public consciousness for a long time, with the minor Channukah
elevated to rominence as part of the backdrop for Christmas.


Yet ANOTHER reason I want them to leave us the hell alone!!!
And keep all the damned stuff OUT of the schools!!! Okay,
that's a different rant....
 
posted by [identity profile] droewyn.livejournal.com at 02:15pm on 2006-10-31
Our local Nordstrom's puts up a tasteful little sign at this time of year telling people to expect their holiday displays to show up on the day after Thanksgiving. We were so thrilled the first time we noticed it that we wrote them a thank-you letter. The response we received thanked us for our feedback and said that they were getting so many positive comments that this was a tradition they were planning on maintaining. So people clearly approve...

If only the *rest* of the mall had their sensibility.
 
posted by [identity profile] figmo.livejournal.com at 02:02am on 2006-11-13
Agreed. "Happy Ramadan" is also very inappropriate; it's up there with "Happy Yom Kippur."

Warren and I were appalled to see Christmas stuff at Costco before Labor Day this year!

Links

January

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31