![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
I'm wondering what my friends (including most of the normally-gendered ones) think of this. With luck, maybe I'll gain important Clue from the discussion.
joeshamo asked, in a
post about Dracula to
transgender, "The question that
comes to my mind is, what do some of you think about the social threat of
changing gender roles?"
I replied:
I know "the social threat of changing gender roles" is something that scares the [expletive] out of a lot of people, but I don't get it. Then again, there's a lot about other people's reactions to us that I just don't get.
I'd say, "Well it didn't trash society when women were finally allowed to vote, or when trousers became acceptable in public for women, or when WWII drew women into the workplace in greater numbers, and those all count as changes to our society's gender roles, so why should any coming changes -- including the ability of an individual to change his/her/hir role at will -- be more of a threat?" But then I remember that a) there are some folks who seem to think that those changes did do nastybad things to our society (no, I don't understand them, I just know they exist), and b) I remember that a lot of people who got used to those changes were pretty put out by them at the time they happened.
Maybe it's just a fear of being lost at sea while new rules are being written? A lot of men seemed to be upset more by being confused as to how they were expected to act than by anything else about the introduction of the "sensitive new-age guy" meme into our culture. I guess change itself is really disturbing to many people.
And bringing it back to the "individuals changing their roles" idea (I wasn't sure from your post which meaning of "changing gender roles" you meant), I guess that people who both a) use the gender of the person they're talking to to determine the rules/template of the interaction, and b) don't have templates for "in between"/"both"/"not sure"/"doesn't matter" and don't improvise well, feel threatened by suddenly not knowing the rules/roles in what is to them a new situation??
Or maybe there's something way more signficiant that I'm just not seeing...?
I'm turning off comments for this post 'cause I want to redirect followups to joeshamo's post instead of spltting the discussion up in two places -- much as I like having comments on my journal, I'd feel like I was stealing the thread or something.