Today's recording session went reasonably well, I think. It looks
like "Argh, it feels like we should've gotten much more done! Wait,
how much did we get done? Hey, that's a reasonable amount. But it
feels like it should have been more!" is getting to be a
pattern for me. I guess I'm just impatient.
Getting there late wasn't a big deal, because Jim was still putting
down tracks for tunes that Mike and I had already recorded our parts
for, so I wasn't actually needed for the first forty minutes I was
there. Jim and I did some tunes together, and there was at least one
that Mike, Jim, and I were all playing on together. I think Mike said
that after today, the strummies are almost caught up to the fiddles in
terms of how many tunes our parts are done on.
One of the things I have to get used to about the Honda is the
small-looking and funny-shaped trunk. The first time I looked at
it, I feared that I wouldn't be able to fit as many instruments into
it as I was used to. Well, it is true that I'm not going to
be able to carry as much equipment in the trunk (and I'm pretty good
at real-world three-dimensional Tetris), but I can get four guitars
in there plus my music bag and my binder of sheet music if I'm careful
and one of the instruments is a solid-body electric. (We didn't wind
up recording any bass tracks, but I had brought my bass just in case.
I did use my twelve-string and six-string folk guitars and my
classical guitar.) There was an amusing moment when I started opening
guitar cases and looked around for stands and didn't see enough
guitar stands. I only saw one empty stand. Emory said, "We can't
possibly be out of guitar stands in this room. We've got lots
of stands." Well, yeah, but also lots of guitars. I was all set to go
fetch the folding stands out of the car, but he found another stand
hiding behind a keyboard, he freed up another stand by putting the
Baby Taylor in its case, and I remembered that I had a tiny folding
stand ("Pocket Titan", IIRC ... which really sounds like something
other than a guitar stand to my ears, but oh well) in the bass guitar's
case.
Listening to Jim through headphones, I noticed how amazingly cool
his cittern sounds amplified. I thought there was some reverb or
chorus on it, but I was told that the signal was completely dry.
Apparently what I was hearing was the result of mixing the direct
signal from the pickup attached to the instrument with the sound
from a mic on a stand in front of it. Very rich, not at all tinny,
while still retaining that distinctive crunch and jangle that makes
the cittern stand out from the guitar and bouzouki. I just wish it
were a bit easier to hear when we're unamplified.
On the one hand, I want the recording part of this project to
be finished already so I can hear what all this work sounds like
mixed down, and so that we can start putting copies into the hands
of our fans. On the other hand, there's still so much I want to
add, so much I want to get exactly right, so many nifty ideas,
that I wish we could afford more studio time. On the
gripping hand, Mike pointed out that by the time we finish all
the tracks we'd planned to record, then cut the list down to what'll
fit on a CD, we'll have enough left over to be a good head start on
our third album.
Recording in ones and twos and threes feels like less pressure
than trying to play a perfect whole-band-at-once take, especially
as I get more accustomed to playing along to other instruments in
my headphones instead of right there in the room with me. It
certainly provides a much cleaner set of tracks for the engineer
to work with at mixdown time.
On the set of tunes I used the classical for, I had originally
planned to play folk guitar. But trying for a particular feel,
it dawned on me that the classical guitar sitting next to me might
better suited what I was trying to do. So I asked the others
whether they thought it made sense to try again using the classical
instead. And it worked. I knew it would sound cool on the second
tune, which has a slow but insistent feel; I wasn't sure how it
would sound when I went to my usual vigorous right hand reel attack
on the third tune. As we hit the transition into the third tune,
I thought, "Well, Flamenco players make it sound right..." then
noticed a measure later that I was moving my right hand and arm
differently than I had five minutes earlier on the steel strings.
My body knew what to do. Listening to playback afterwards, it all
worked, but there was a surprise waiting. Emory threw the previous
take into the headphone mix, so we were hearing nylon strings in
one ear and steel strings in the other -- I'd thought about possibly
layering the two sounds -- and it turned out I'd put accents in
different places in the two takes in one section so that one guitar
answered the other, completely unintentionally. Bonus! I don't know
whether we're going to use both together in the final mix, but it's
being considered.
I sometimes wonder how much of a rut I let myself get into with
some of these tunes, and whether I'm at the right balance point
between everyone in the band knowing what to expect from each
other and "keeping it fresh" (especially making the second and
third repetition of a tune in a set not sound like a cut-and-paste
of the first). I'm still not sure how I'm doing on that scrore in
general, but at least I know that particular set is still fresh.
Like I said, it felt like we didn't do enough, but looking back at
what we did, it was more than it felt like.