eftychia: Me in kilt and poofy shirt, facing away, playing acoustic guitar behind head (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] eftychia at 01:08pm on 2004-05-06

Tuesday night, [livejournal.com profile] xpioti gave me my first PDA, an old Handspring Visor. When I heard about palmtop devices, I thought the idea sounded interesting but worried about how much computing power one could fit there, and the user interace. When my friends started getting them, I thought they looked potentially useful, with both advantages and disadvangtages compared to my paper DayRunner, and had no idea whether I would find such a thing useful, whether the UI would drive me crazy, whether it would replace my DayRunner or augment it ... it was an "I'll have to try one for a week or a month someday" thing.

Now I've got my hands on one. I'm adapting to Graffiti (the stylus-stroke text entry system) much more quickly than I expected to (though the stroke for '9' is so different from how I write a nine that I still have to stop and think, I'm not making my gestures large enough[1], and I still have to look up most of the punctuation). But despite the poor contrast (especially compared to black ink on white paper), the slower handwriting, and not being able to see as much of what I'd written earlier at a time, I do find I'm reaching for the smaller device that I don't have to physically flip open to the right page to use before I reach for my familiar DayRunner.

Last night I sent the following to a general-discussion mailing list (so a bunch of my LJ friends will have seen it already):

Subject: Tell me what to do with my Visor

I was just given a used Handspring Visor Platinum. It's running PalmOS 3.5.2H1. What does the Elbows hive mind consider essential downloads (starting with free ones) to install, and why? And are there better sites (in terms of selection and/or site useability and organization) to look for downloads than www.handspring.com and www.palm.com?

I've seen such devices in friends' hands, but I'm only just now holding one and starting to get ideas for how it might be useful to me. I'm still at the stage of figuring out what questions I should be asking/Googling.

After spending a day entering calendar events, writing down the stuff I usually record during the day in my DayRunner, and even downloading a book reader and a copy of Free Culture, which John has been telling me I absolutely must read, and then reading the responses so far to my request for suggestions, my impression is this:

This device is really pretty much a Toy out of the box (though as has been pointed out to me, for some people the built-in calendar/addressbook/to-do list are enough to be useful), but it seems that if I install the right combination of third-party software, it'll turn into a powerful and extremely personally customized Serious Tool with a bunch of toys tacked on.

So now I need to spend a while surfing the sites folks have pointed me at, looking for the components that'll make this toy my tool, find the tools I'll need to write my own programs for it, and then spend a week or two asking myself what else I wish it would do. In a couple of months we'll see whether it has become a prosthetic brain crucial to life support, or simply a more powerful toy with some convenient tools folded in. Very early data suggest the former, but the jury is out. That it will at least be useful seems a pretty safe bet.

And since I've got two cradles (a serial one and a USB one), and like to be able to do most things from both the office (where the Windows machines are) and the bedroom (Mac), I need to find out whether hotsyncing to two different computers will completely bollix things up. (I should be able to set up both desktop hotsync apps to store things in the same directory on my fileserver ... unless they keep some of the info in the Windows registry or someplace in the System folder on the Mac.)

Now to look for music tools (an ABC reader perhaps?) and either a spreadsheet or a database where I get to define the records.


[1] When I was in Montessori, I liked to write small. Some of my classmates and I would have contests to see who could write (legibly) the smallest. We got so small that we had to sharpen the pencil again every few letters lest the thickness of the line grow larger than the shapes of the letters. (I'm not exaggerating for effect here -- that's literally what we did. I think we got into an argument once over whether it still counted as legible if a magnifying glass was needed.) We only wrote a few words at a time that small, for our little competitions, but my handwriting in general started tending toward the small size. Then in seventh grade I had a math teacher who couldn't read my handwriting because it was too small, and she insisted that I write larger. The quality of my handwriting started its decline at that point, and I'm disinclined to think that's mere coincidence (not only because of the timing, but also because I later noticed that when I write smaller I write more neatly, even if I'm writing at similar speed). In college I was briefly able to get ahold of narrow-ruled notebooks, and sometimes put two lines of notes per line on the paper when sitting in note-intensive lectures (such as Theatre History, a core requirement that I enjoyed far more than I expected to, enough so that I went back for the second semester of it as an elective). I used to put three lines of handwritten notes per line of normal-ruled paper. Nowadays the smallest I can find is college-ruled, which is noticeably larger. I miss narrow-rule. But I digress. Anyhow, when I'm writing on the Visor, I'm thinking "precision" because a dumb device has to be able to recognize my strokes ... and so I automatically make my motions smaller, which is the opposite of what the Visor wants. So I've got to re-train myself like I did in seventh grade, all over again.

Oddly enough, my taste for very sharp pencils and very fine lines eventually left me frustrated with a device I had to sharpen so bloody often to keep it comfortable (and back then the 0.1 mm mechanical pencils weren't around, at least not any that I ever saw), so I switched to ball point pens because they never needed sharpening, and just adjusted to never having a really fine line, but never having it get any worse. This raised eyebrows when I got to college and people noticed that while most students liked pens, all but one of the math majors preferred pencils, and I was the oddball in the math department.

But my wishes for precision and control and a comfortable feel, evenness of line and reliability, do leave me picky about my pens. I use cheap disposables most of the time (though I've got a Cross in my DayRunner), but I definitely have my favourite brands and detested brands. I've not yet found the perfect pen (can I have something that makes a perfectly even, extremely fine line like a Rapidograph and feels like one as it does so, but writes at any angle to the paper, as a felt-tip does, with ink that dries so quickly that I never need to worry about the dreaded southpaw smudge, and a barrel custom fit exactly to my hand?), but I'm always picking up unfamiliar pens and trying them out when I see a display.

Fountain pens are a whole 'nuther thing, and probably warrant their own journal entry (even though it'll be shorter than this footnote).

There are 10 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] redaxe.livejournal.com at 10:11am on 2004-05-06
I remember being at Pennsic one year and meeting Lyrra post a class of hers in how to use a diptych. She was highly amused because Graffiti so closely resembled the stylus style taught in class for use in wax. What goes around...
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 11:22am on 2004-05-06
Oh, that reminds me -- I need to make sure to save up for one of those this Pennsic. I was eyeing them last year and thinking that one would very neatly handle most of what I wanted my DayRunner for while walking around, and I could remove one more blatantly modern item. Anything I needed to save longer than a day or two, I could copy to my DayRunner back in camp.

Then again, since the Visor will slip neatly into a belt pouch ...

... Nah, I still want the wax tablet book even if I don't really need it now. More into the experience, and all that.
mneme: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] mneme at 10:30am on 2004-05-06
Already gave you advice on palmos software.

Though this is what you want in terms of ABC

Re "how much computing power can you fit in one of these"...they've got Atari Fucking ST emulators for the upper-end palms now. Not to mention full-speed gameboy em's (last time I was running one, it was a bit sluggish, but that was on a IIIxe; my handera is faster than that, and the new palms are amazingly faster).

Oh, you're going to want to do some investigation on development tools, since there are a -lot- of options -- cross-compiling with GCC; java via WABA or better yet, Jump (compile Java into 680xx assembler for the palm), lispme, etc.

mneme: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] mneme at 11:12am on 2004-05-06
Also, there's a staff-wise ABC viewer on the palm as well.
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 11:16am on 2004-05-06
Yeah, but when I first heard about them, before any of my friends could afford one, was a long time ago now ... (any my impression of how difficult it would be to cram a lot of computing power into that small a space was probably wrong then as well, but it wasn't as silly-wrong as it would be nowadays). I probably should have mentioned that that particular concern had vanished quite some time ago.

Off to look at that ABC tool now...
 
posted by [identity profile] doubleplus.livejournal.com at 11:39am on 2004-05-06
That's the one I have. I've never been a very intense geek (after a day of programming at work, I'm not terribly enthused about doing it for fun) so I don't actually do a lot with mine. I like it a lot for keeping packing and shopping lists (I'm much less likely to forget something when I have a master list of everything I've ever packed, and can uncheck the ones I want for this trip to start the process.) Also for notes that I used to keep on scraps of paper, since I always have it with me and can find them. Oh, and the backlighting is very useful for directions when I'm driving at night.

Let me know if you find good software. Also, if you find any good video games, I have a "Game Face" for it, which snaps on and has a joystick that pushes the buttons underneath. I picked it up for five bucks in a clearance bin, and I've never used it, so you're welcome to it if you want it.
 
posted by [identity profile] number-12.livejournal.com at 12:33pm on 2004-05-06
Write 9 as a backwards 3

PDB explorer -- to edit palm databases directly, good for doing things on the PC to files for tools that aren't part of the PALM desktop program.

ExpenseLogPro makes keeping track of receipts easy (necessary if you obsessively want to track every one like I do), and you can trick it into being a gas mileage calculator

Get a fold-up keyboard. Use Ebay to get the compatible one and don't settle for anything less than full-size keys.

In the other direction, a very small thumb board makes data entry while standing in lines, etc, a little easier if you get tired of Grafitti.

$.02

 
posted by [identity profile] thette.livejournal.com at 09:46pm on 2004-05-06
I second the keyboard recommendation, and don't recommend the Belkin foldable one. Get a keyboard that's connected, not an infrared one; they're too sensitive.

If you want to read books on it, which I found very convenient, Plucker converts HTML to something readable and relatively small. (And there are e-books in HTML over at Baen, both in their free library and in the books one have to buy.)
jducoeur: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] jducoeur at 09:46am on 2004-05-07
I can't use it any more (having upgraded to a Treo, with a crappy but integral keyboard), but I was very fond of the Stowaway keyboard when I was using a Visor. While it's not exactly a great keyboard, it's comparable to a typical notebook, so it serves decently well when one needs to take serious notes. And it folds nice and small. (And it's simply one of the coolest toys around: an exceptional piece of mechanical engineering.)

The other must-have for me is SmartDoc -- which lets you *write* in the usual reader format as well as read it. It's uncompressed, but it allows you to have notes of unlimited length. (The 4K limit to memos is one of the major irritations of Palm OS, IMO.)
 
posted by [identity profile] syntonic-comma.livejournal.com at 10:26pm on 2004-05-14
Tell me what to do with my Visor

Well, first you get a bicycle. Then you connect your PDA to it as your speedometer and far more. Besides the obvious advantages of a (relatively) huge display area and whatever statistical processing you might want to come up with, organized (group) rides have these things called "cue sheets" -- a list of waypoints and turns by cumulative distance. If you put the cue sheet into the PDA, this setup can tell you how far it is to each next turn.

Links

January

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31