eftychia: Me in kilt and poofy shirt, facing away, playing acoustic guitar behind head (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] eftychia at 12:52pm on 2002-12-26

I just got a message from my brother: the group of them (brother, mother, aunt, uncle, cousins) are at the Inner Harbor, seeing the sights, shopping, going to the aquarium, etc., and thought I might want to join them.

I do. I especially want to spend more time with my cousins while they're in town, and it'd be kind of neat to spend some time with folks in "my space" (Baltimore being closer to that than anyplace else we're likely to meet, unless I do some MAJOR housecleaning in the next hour and somehow convince them to come to my house, fifteen minutes West of the harbour).

But there's the Mom/clothing issue. Nine years ago, in response to a request from Mom when I came out to my parents as transgendered, I agreed that I would wear boyclothes to her house. She wanted me to promise to wear boyclothes whenever I was around her; I modified that before agreeing to anything. She's never seen me dressed as *me*. I wore a kilt to my brother's wedding (not the brother who's in Baltimore today). When I've gone to my brother's in-laws for holidays I've worn pants because I figured it wasn't the right time to push things, especially with all the financial help I've been depending on Mom for lately. But this is ... well, my ground. It's not a holiday party or a wedding. It's fifteen minutes from my house, and a place I wander around with a camera some nights. At the same time, the first time Mom sees me dressed as myself, it's going to come across as a challenge. I don't want to antagonize her. I just don't want to have to keep putting on a disguise if she's going to be around.

Morally, I feel there's nothing wrong with my choosing my own clothes today. Politically is another matter. Just not showing up would suck too, 'cause this is a chance to spend more time with my aunt, uncle, and cousins without driving very far.

Interestingly, this topic came up with my sister in law last night. With all the slush on the ground, I didn't want to wear my flats, so I wore my cute boots and brought my innocuous flats to change into so as to not freak out my mother. My sister in law thought that was silly, and convinced me to leave the boots on (which I was happier about wearing in the first place, slush or no slush); she also chided me for choosing a more conservative top instead of the more festive one that I'd feared would bother Mom. She pointed out that in her parents' house, her family's judgement about what's apropriate should prevail over my mother's. She's right, but there's the question of how far/how fast it's practical to try to push Mom. (Note that her family's reactions to my cape probably had a lot to do with Mom's decision to buy me fabric to get it re-lined -- everyone over there thinks my cape is just the coolest thing, and tells Mom that when she tries to apologize for how "odd" I am for wearing it.)

Folks are supposed to go over to my brother's house sometime before the visiting kinfolk fly back to England, and my sister in law told me she expects me to come as myself, not in my visiting-mommy-disguise, so the issue is likely to be right in Mom's face soon anyhow ... but I'm still nervous about it. The memory of Mom's reaction to that phone conversation nearly a decade ago still stings ... but so does the reminder each time I put on a completely different look just to do family stuff. (All Come Free, while being more about my reaction to my parents' reactions to my coming out, has more to do with Mom's reaction than to Dad's, and also reflects the feelings of the decade leading up to my telling them, when all my friends and many strangers knew, but not my folks).

At my brother's house, I'll have my sister in law, at the very least, standing up to my Mom and arguing my side, plus I'll have the excuse that I was honoring the wishes of the hostess. But it'll still be tense with Mom. Today, while it's "my city", it's technically neutral ground -- the unspoken rules are all different. And my sister in law won't be there. And complete strangers will be -- I'm sure Mom will react to the "public embarrassment" aspect of drawing attention. On the other hand, it's one of the places that I go on my time, a place that's part of my non-family stomping ground. Putting on the boyclothes disguise to go there feels like ... well, wimping out for sure, but also "cheating" somehow.

I don't know yet what I'm going to do. I can go in Glenn-clothes, go in boyclothes, make an excuse and not go ... I'm going to go take a shower and then decide.

I hate this stress, I hate it I hate it I hate it. One of the Big Important Advantages of being OUT is that I don't have to worry about how people will react when They Find Out, but there are still these little corners of shadows and greys and tense situations to deal with. It's not [expletive]ing fair. (Of those corners, this is the most serious. There are other, smaller ones.) When I made my peace with dressing as Myself and [expletive] what the rest of the world thinks, it was supposed to free me from this whole, "Do I have the nerve to actually walk out the door dressed like this?" panic -- and mostly it did so (though, oddly, I sometimes feel that when going out in boyclothes -- go figure). I resent Mom for her part in my feeling like a scared, closeted eighteen year old again, even though on her side it's just wanting to protect herself from something she sees as unpleasant.

Then again, if I take too long writing this, they'll finish their sightseeing and go home and my decision will be moot. Guess I'd better go take that shower.

Mood:: tense
There are 11 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
cellio: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] cellio at 10:06am on 2002-12-26
Ouch. This is an awful situation to have to be in. {hugs}

Is there anything in your Glenn wardrobe that is more "ambiguous", that sends the dual messages of "this is my turf, dammit" and "I am at least trying to not cause a scene with you, Mom"? The kilt would be one example of this; some SCA garb would also qualify (I don't know what periods you do in the SCA). Of course, of this I don't know what's actually comfortable in December, so forgive me if this is a stupid idea. Just trying to help. You should not have to wear boy clothes, and I understand the desire to not have a confrontation today, so I'm looking for compromise options.
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 10:39am on 2002-12-26
[Just got out of the shower (I did a little more work on the brass thingies that were supposed to be finished by Christmas, first), about to pick what to wear. Glad I checked for comments.]

I did think of wearing garb -- probably Norman (at least I think it's Norman) --or my kilt. I've got stuff that'd be comfortable enough temperature-wise today. I don't think I'm going to do that, but as of this moment, it's still an option.

I do often try to schedule visits to Mom's house on the way to or from a performance, so that I'll already be in boyclothes and won't have to feel like I've dressed up especially for her. So that usually means kilt or garb.

Today, I suspect that'd seem more obviously "costume" than anything else I could wear. It'd feel sort of a little of both sides to me.

Still thinking.

And thanks.
 
posted by [identity profile] kathrynt.livejournal.com at 11:54am on 2002-12-26
Do you own any glenn-clothes that don't involve skirts? In my extremely limited experience, if you showed up in (say) a decent blouse and a sweater and a pair of nice chick slacks, that will make your point (that's definitely not a boy outfit) without pushing your mother into conniptions. You're doing an excellent job of respecting your mother's wishes, but at some point, that respect has to go both ways.
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 02:11pm on 2002-12-26
I need to lose many pounds before I'll try wearing my leopard-print spandex pants again, and the only other pants I've got are the black dress slacks that I've been wearing as boyclothes. (They actually come from the women's department, but that's for reasons of fit; I think of them as "boy" because the only reason I own them is for the times I have to wear something that passes for boyclothes.) So wearing those still counts (in my emotional response) as donning the visit-mom disguise.

At the Christmas party last night, I wore the black slacks with a long-sleeved black velour top. At Mom's house Christmas Eve, I wore a red polo shirt with the black slacks, and my cousins were amazed that I was in short sleeves (it wasn't that cold Tuesday night, and I had my cape).
ext_4917: (Default)
posted by [identity profile] hobbitblue.livejournal.com at 11:59am on 2002-12-26
I've only been reading your journal for a little while, and while I knew you were transgendered, the whole "beard and a skirt and heels" aspect hadn't really registered with me... On reading this post (and scooting to your webpage to get to know you better, I should have done that before, sorry) I reckon that on your own home ground you should wear whatever the hell you like, and your mom really should have got the idea by now. I know its hard to upset moms, but there are various famous men who happily wear skirts and dresses (Eddie Izzard, that French fashion designer who's name currently escapes me, various others) so why shouldn't you? If it were up to me, I'd say go on the kilt and keep the rest low-key (never a good idea to be challenging this time of year) but stop wearing pants around your mom, she'll have to get used ot it sooner or later.

She really can't complain about kilts if the likes of Samuel L Jackson can spend an entire film wearing one (51st State) - and I know life is about more than Hollywood, but such images as you know carry ideas of what is and isn't "acceptable" and might help her out.

But we dion't know each otehr, so feel very free to ignore my views completely, hope you get to hang out with your family and still feel like "you", however you end up dressing :)
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 02:15pm on 2002-12-26
I'm not going to ignore your take on this completely -- hey, we know each other a little from reading each others' journals, and Clue is Clue, n'est-ce pas?

I hadn't thought of using Eddie Izzard's existence as something to throw into the discussion -- guess I ought to use that while folks are visiting from England, rather than later...

As for what I wound up doing, I'm about to write a fresh post about that.
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 01:30am on 2002-12-27
BTW, my kilt is far and away the most masculine-feeling thing in my wardrobe. I never feel more butch, more macho, more masculine (maybe even more male) than in a kilt. So in one sense a kilt is even less of a compromise than wearing trousers, since it's uber-male. (OTOH, I cope better with wearing a kilt because it registers as "stage clothes" for me, like garb does, so it doesn't push the same "in disguise in the world" buttons.)
ext_4917: (Default)
posted by [identity profile] hobbitblue.livejournal.com at 08:42am on 2002-12-30
I suppose it is very male.. certainly one needs to be confident of oneself to wear a kilt outside of Scotland or RenFaire.. I wonder if thats how others percieve it though?
 
posted by [identity profile] cyan-blue.livejournal.com at 09:08pm on 2002-12-26
It sounds like it's really eating at you to keep doing what pleases your Mom in this. You've tried it for a lot of years, but it doesn't get easier; it feels more and more like suppressing the core of yourself.

It sounds like it may be time to tell your Mom that you love her but need to dress in the way that meets the needs of your own spirit from now on. That she can love *you* best by honoring how, and who, you truly are - not by thinking first of what others will say.

Are there other parents-of-transfolks who she can talk to, to help her get used to acceptance? Pride, even?

Geri
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 01:22am on 2002-12-27
"It sounds like it's really eating at you to keep doing what pleases your Mom in this. You've tried it for a lot of years, but it doesn't get easier; it feels more and more like suppressing the core of yourself."

That's an accurate reflection of part of what I said (perhaps the most important part). And yes, that's been gnawing at me for years, both before and after coming out to her. And you're right, it's not getting easier.

I sometimes feel sick to my stomach when contemplating visiting my mother, because it upsets me so much to have to put on a disguise to visit the closest of family. Of course, she can't see that; she only sees that I showed up, and that I did so dressed "apropriately". How difficult it was for me to do so is completely invisible unless describe it (and she comprehends/believes the description), but I don't do so because that would feel like re-starting an already-fought fight.

"It sounds like it may be time to tell your Mom that you love her but need to dress in the way that meets the needs of your own spirit from now on."

She can be as stubborn as I am. It's long past time I should've said that, but I fear a rift ... then again, if things are heading in that direction anyhow, maybe I have less to lose than I'd thought.

"That she can love *you* best by honoring how, and who, you truly are - not by thinking first of what others will say."

The question is how to say that in a way that she'll hear it. In many ways, her ears are closed. I need to sneak the message in via the paths still open.

(I don't expect you to be able to tell me how to do that -- I'm pretty sure that requires knowing my mother pretty well. But if you have generic Clue to share, things I haven't thought of that I can figure out how well they apply, I'll listen.)

It really feels as though she doesn't love me, but rather that she loves the son I'm supposed to have been (as long as she can pretend that I really am him). But I know how much I hate it when someone plays the "If you loved me..." card on me, so I'm skittish about saying things that even sound like that.

(I've got more to say about "if you love..." in the rant that's brewing about what happened a few hours ago.)

"Are there other parents-of-transfolks who she can talk to, to help her get used to acceptance? Pride, even?"

Sometime in the past decade, PFLAG changed from, "Uh [scratches head] I guess parents of transfolk might fit in here..." to explicitly including transgendered in their literature. So yes, there's PFLAG for her to talk to, but first I have to get her to want to talk to anyone about it.

Geri, thank you.
 
posted by [identity profile] cyan-blue.livejournal.com at 08:33am on 2002-12-27
> But if you have generic Clue to share, things I haven't thought of that I can figure
> out how well they apply, I'll listen.

I don't have the magic phrase, of course. But it occurs to me that this may not be so much about *what* you say, as about your willingness to say it and stick by it. I mean, you'll likely put in the usual stuff about "Mom, I love you, and making you happy is important to me - so important that I've honored your wishes about my garb for X years. But it's eating me up inside to have to maintain a facade, especially to the one who I'd love the most to know me - the real me. I can no longer pretend I am other than who I am, and I want to honor you by letting you get to know the real me. And I want you to honor me in turn by welcoming and accepting the real me."

Or something like that.

But really, if she's going to hear it, she'll hear it; if she's inclined not to, she won't. And it comes down to, who is going to be the one to draw the line?

What will happen if you simply tell her some variant of the above, finishing with "And I am going to dress as *me* from now on, and you will have to accept that." Will she grit her teeth and put up with it? Go along with it but make snide remarks? Say she never wants to see you again?

And how well can you withstand each of these?

Hugs,
Geri

Links

January

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31