eftychia: Me in kilt and poofy shirt, facing away, playing acoustic guitar behind head (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] eftychia at 12:46pm on 2003-11-20

I'm still in a write-more-than-respond headspace for now.

Today is a day to remind people to remember tell everyone to get angry enough to do something about a whole lot of people who die for what has to be one of the stupidest reasons.

"Because you don't like the way they dress," or "because they're different," or even, "because they're confusing," are pretty stupid reasons to murder somebody. Not only is the act tragic and unjust; it's also a pretty fucking pointless reason for violence. Not that there are many good reasons for murder, but at least there's some kind of ... well, "sense" I guess ... to political assassinations, robberies gone bad, jealous rage, drug turf wars, or revenge for other murders. Those are still Bad Things, but at least I can understand them. But to kill somebody because you don't like their clothes? Or because you can't quite figure out whether you're "supposed" to find them attractive or not? That's just dumb.

But apparently there are memes out there that say it's okay to beat up or kill someone whose gender identity is confusing or surprising or just "unapproved"; and that violence against transgendered people is somehow "expected" (as in police statements along the lines of, "we don't expect to find the killer because transgendered people around here have a lot of enemies"); and that being surprised or confused is an excuse even if it's not a valid justification (the "homosexual panic defense", for example); and that the lives or transgendered people aren't worth as much effort when it comes to bringing their attackers to justice, providing protection when threats have been made, or even, in some cases, providing adequate treatement of their injuries.

Fortunately there are competing memes that label hate crimes especially disgusting (whether increased penalties for hate crimes are warranted or not), or at least that nobody deserves to be attacked merely for being different. We need these anti-violence memes to spread.

Today is the Transgender Day of Remembrance. Damn near everyone who reads my journal probably understands the issue, but I'm sure some don't think about it all that often unless they're reading a news story about a transgendered victim at the time, so this entry is a reminder. And I'm sure some of my friends do think about the problem more often, but don't find opportunities to mention it in conversation with random people who might not have thought about it at all. And there may be a few who hear anti-TG statements and don't object to them for fear of "making a scene".

Today, I ask all of you for a favour: mention it. Spread the "TG people don't deserve violence" meme. Spread awareness that in many parts of the world, including the United States, this is an ongoing problem -- that people do get killed for wearing the "wrong" clothes or using the "wrong" pronouns -- and attach a meme that says what a horrible thing that is.

In return, I promise to try not to get beaten up or killed this year, okay?

Last year I posted an entry that explained, among other things, why I don't feel all that much personal fear when I'm out in public. That's all still true. So instead of asking you to spread these memes for my personal protection, I'm asking you to do it just because it's something I feel is terribly important. Put a bug in someone's ear today so that the next time they hear about a TG murder, instead of thinking, "And he was wearing a dress -- isn't that silly?" they'll think, "Wow, that's part of a pattern I've heard about ... and that's horrible." So that instead of thinking, "Well he/she was asking for it," they'll think, "Wow, that's just as bad as if somebody killed a cisgendered male or a cisgendered female simply for being male or female. How scary it is that there are people who could think that way." (Okay, I don't expect you do conduct a major re-education campaign; just to put the memes out there to start the ball rolling.) I know a lot of people, but all of you put together know a lot more people, and besides, most of the people I know have already been exposed to anti-violence and transgendered-people-are-just-people memes. You know I'll do the same for some of your causes.

Just say something.

Thanks.

There are 9 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] aliza250.livejournal.com at 10:09am on 2003-11-20
"Wow, that's just as bad as if somebody killed a cisgendered male or a cisgendered female simply for being male or female. How scary it is that there are people who could think that way."

Well, there are lots of women killed just for being female. Ans it is scary.

But I do get your drift.
 
posted by [identity profile] dglenn.livejournal.com at 10:38am on 2003-11-20
True. I should have said, "when somebody kills" instead of "if somebody killed". I'm not sure whether I should edit the entry or just leave it here in the comments.
 
posted by [identity profile] harpwolf.livejournal.com at 08:08pm on 2003-11-26
Sure. I've heard of a woman assaulted near to death for doing something boys often do... all within a queer feminist community, while community members side with the perp and strain for PC ways to say "she asked for it". What's sad is they never even notice their own dripping misogyny... they just assume their self-appellation of "feminist" is accurate.

The lesson I got is that misogyny is such a powerful cultural groupthink, that I need to be oh so careful not to fall into it. Coz nobody's immune.
 
posted by [identity profile] still-asking.livejournal.com at 10:44am on 2003-11-20
Not that I doubt the importance of the issue, on the contrary! I'll just have to educate on a more relaxed schedule as today's plan involves staying home and sanding the kitchen (long story) and the only other person I'm likely to see is Tangent.

Which reminds me - this didn't come in either or our sizes, but it's cool.



</a
 
posted by [identity profile] lothie.livejournal.com at 04:38pm on 2003-11-20
Yanno...I know I myself don't "get" everything about transgenderism. Like I get mtf and ftm, but I'm less "getty" about the "I'm not either gender, I'm something else" aspect of things, even though you'd think, given my own mental map, that that's the one that would make most sense to me. Compartmentalism, I guess.

But I think the thing I don't get about it the most is why the fuck people need to abuse TG folk. What the FUCK are they threatened by????? I will not understand it even in a million years.

God bless us, every one.

Thanks for introducing me to the term cisgendered btw.
cellio: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] cellio at 08:41am on 2003-11-21
But I think the thing I don't get about it the most is why the fuck people need to abuse TG folk.

More generally, I don't get why people have to abuse people who are not like them and who aren't hurting anyone. It's revolting.

There's probably also a side case of treating men differently from women. Most of the attacks on homosexuals we hear about are on gay men, not lesbians. And it's not very obvious from the outside if a woman thinks of herself as a man, because unless she starts wearing suits with ties she's probably dressed the same way as most women who don't do dresses, at least to the casual observer. And for some reason, there is this meme of "men must be many MEN, not sissies in dresses" among some of the less-enlightened folks out there. Bah.
 
posted by [identity profile] lothie.livejournal.com at 03:09pm on 2003-11-21
Well, I could be wrong, but aren't most of the people who are attacked, attacked because there was a perception they came onto the attacker? In other words, there's a "oh my god I [almost] fucked that" thing going on.

I could be wrong.
cellio: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] cellio at 02:39pm on 2003-11-24
I don't have any statistics to evaluate "most", but I know I've read newspaper accounts of cases where attackers went into gay bars to pick someone up for the express purpose of beating him up or worse. Isn't that what happened to Matthew Shepard?
 
posted by [identity profile] lothie.livejournal.com at 03:00pm on 2003-11-24
I dunno, I thought their being in the same bar was coincidence.

But I don't really know. I do think it's disgusting. If it's not something you want, just leave it alone, sez I.

Links

January

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31